Sunday, October 14, 2012

Response to the Moonstone


Hannah Martinez
Kristen Hague
English Literature
12 October 2012

Bog #3-Moonstone
            As English majors we are used to being assigned many different types of reading. Sometimes they are fun and interesting and then there are ones that just aren’t our cup of tea. With the majority of all my English and literature classes behind me, I have completed my fair share of reading assignments at CMU, however I must say that our reading assignment of the Moonstone written by Wilkie Collins is by far, one of my favorites! This was one of those novels you could not put down and you can’t wait to see what the outcome of the ending is going to be (at least for me J).
            In the event of this not completely sounding like a book report, I truly enjoyed and appreciated this novel. Collins writes in a fashion that is effective, interesting and in a way that creates a relationship between the reader and her characters. The entire time in reading this book I felt as if I was right there, involved with what the characters were experiencing, as well as felt emotions with them when they themselves, where feeling the emotions. The ending was exactly what I had expected and completely surprising all in the same manner. Throughout the second half of the book I felt as if Godfrey Ablewhite had been pinned as having a large hand in the disappearance of the Moonstone but what I did not expect was the way in which it was laid into his hands and for the reasons he proceeded to take it. It was a fascinating way to end this story that was told from some many different perspectives. I loved the conclusion of this novel! While I had never read mystery novels before, I feel as if Collins goes beyond the expectations in concluding this story.
            Collins does not just allude to a person who committed the crime. She does that, and then takes not just one step further, but several, to the point that no one would’ve seen the entire extent of it coming. How interesting is it that Franklin had truly been the one to steal the diamond and then hand it off to Godfrey, when Godfrey could then use it to his benefit?! I believe the many twists that are tied to Godfrey’s character really make this story so great. He needed money, but he had not predetermined to take or steal anything, and yet an extremely valuable but stolen diamond is placed in his hands when he wasn’t the one that truly “stole” it. There are so many significant details to every event and every character in this book that it would take pages and pages to revisit each one, but they all contribute to the brilliance of Collins writing. I would love to have been a fly on the wall through the process of her writing the Moonstone because as a consumer you know that every aspect of this story had thorough and processed thought that went into it.
            To say the least, I really loved this novel. It introduced me to many new ideas, from the genre to the time period and even to the themes, this book brings you through several entities to enjoy. As I said, I appreciated this book I did not just like it. The way Collins writes and tells her story through the use of her many characters makes the reader appreciate her contribution to literature through her novel the Moonstone.

3 comments:

  1. I would definitely agree with your idea that while reading it you felt like you were right there. For me, it was all of the records that were used to establish some type of truth. It felt more like a documentary rather than a fictional mystery. The hardest thing for me is that I always fall for the author's masqarade of possible suspects. I know that the ending result should surprise me and I should expect the unexpected as the guilty personnel, but for some reason I cannot step out of the reading to make an analysis based on possibilities. I always fall for it!! I think that is why people enjoy novels such as these so much.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm so glad you liked the novel, Hannah. It's a great example of Victorian fiction and happens to be an interesting read. You should give The Woman in White" a try; people are pretty split as to which novel is stronger.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I would also have to agree with Hannah about liking The Moonstone. It was very refreshing to have a novel that you could get lost in instead of having to constantly decipher tough language, or read an old author that is interesting, but not so much on the "fun" side. I also thought it was pretty cool that this novel was basically the first of this genre. When we look at all the mystery media we have today, it is everywhere! I feel like I have another feather in my cap for reading the first of a very large, popular genre.

    ReplyDelete